Statement Regarding Acceptable Taste

The term "acceptable taste" aligns with the Barbershop Harmony Society’s mission, vision, values, and code of ethics. It includes content (visual, verbal, and written) that is inclusive, respectful, and appropriate for a multi-generational audience. Performances should avoid overtly political, overtly sexualized, or overtly offensive content, and should not defame or belittle others.

The definition of these terms will ultimately be the responsibility of the CEO. However, decisions will not be made alone or without input from others. Harmony Hall will create a diverse and inclusive advisory group (with representation from Contest & Judging) that will review BHS operational materials, products, and services. These reviews will incorporate continuous process improvements to ensure that we are serving our members and the world in alignment with the "Statement Regarding Acceptable Taste".

Yes, interpretations can vary. To address this, the Society will rely on a transparent and inclusive review process involving input from diverse perspectives. Feedback channels will also be open to address concerns and refine guidelines as needed.

Performers and members can provide feedback by completing the feedback form. In the future, interested parties can provide feedback through designated channels, such as surveys, town halls, or direct communication with Society leadership. These channels will be clearly communicated to all stakeholders.

The advisory group will review the withheld videos to see if they are in alignment with the "Statement Regarding Acceptable Taste." Decisions are anticipated to be made by April 1, 2025.

All BHS operational materials, products, and services will be reviewed including sheet music for sale and current YouTube videos available.

If a performance, material, product, or service is found to violate the guidelines, the Society will address the matter respectfully with those involved, providing guidance and feedback. Any actions taken will be in alignment with the Society’s commitment to inclusivity and respect, including removing products from availability and not posting performances on YouTube, as examples.

The guidelines are not intended to stifle creativity but to encourage thoughtful artistry that resonates and makes a diverse audience feel welcome. Performers are encouraged to express themselves while adhering to the principles outlined in the statement.

Compliance will be reviewed through proactive quarterly assessments. The review process will be carried out by a diverse group of stakeholders to ensure fairness and objectivity.

The quarterly reviews will evaluate performances, materials, products, and services based on their alignment with the "Statement Regarding Acceptable Taste," considering factors such as inclusivity, respect, and appropriateness for a diverse audience. Feedback from members and performers will also inform the review process.

The Society is committed to ensuring fairness and objectivity in applying the guidelines. A diverse review process, clear criteria, and open communication will help mitigate risks of bias or censorship.

The "Statement Regarding Acceptable Taste" seeks to honor the Society’s historical roots while addressing the evolving expectations of a diverse, multi-generational audience. It aims to preserve barbershop traditions while fostering inclusivity.

The intent of the statement is not to over-regulate but to provide a framework that aligns with the Society’s mission. Efforts will be made to communicate this clearly and address any concerns of overreach or alienation.

If you have questions about contestability, please complete this form, and a member of the Contestability Committee will reply.